Wit Capital, a 33-person broker dealer that conducts its investment-banking business exclusively on the Internet, is causing tremors on Wall Street.
The digital upstart and National Association of Securities Dealers member firm is offering prospective individual investors access to initial public offerings and other early-stage investment instruments, including plans for a series of angel funds.
"There's no doubt in my mind about the power of the retail investor," said Bob Lessin, New York-based Wit Capital's recently-appointed chairman, and one of Wall Street's high net-worth investment experts, or angel investors. "It's a powerful constituency. As more mergers create [brokerage] behemoths, it is clear there is an underserved niche."
Since opening its capital-markets operation in September, Wit Capital's customers have participated in 12 IPOs originated by ten lead managers, including deals by New York-based firms Bear, Stearns & Co., PaineWebber and Prudential Securities, and Baltimore-based BT Alex. Brown.
In a landscape where the giants keep more of the IPO pie, will such a retail-oriented strategy succeed? One thing is certain: Lessin and his heavy-hitting management team are already raising eyebrows on Wall Street.
"What they're doing is our competition," noted the head of one New York-based syndicate desk. "With their management team, they could be very competitive with full-service brokerages."
Antidote Against Flippers
A key to Wit Capital's underwriting success, according to sources, will be convincing other syndicate members and companies that retail distribution means quality distribution. Critics charge that some retail investors referred to as flippers are quick to take profits in an offering's first day of trading.
Wit Capital's ability to track its customers' trades should discourage flipping. What's more, Wit Capital has another tool to discourage customers from cashing their shares during the first 60 days of an offering: penalties and exclusion from future IPOs.
"We ask investors to make long-term investments," said William Feeley, Wit Capital's director of capital markets. "And, so far, our clients have been aftermarket buyers in every issue but one."
Placing stock directly digital-affinity distribution in the hands of a company's trusted stakeholders, such as customers and employees, is perhaps Wit Capital's best antidote for flipping.
The new technology enables Wit Capital to:
* Tap an issuer's roster of customers, employees and suppliers.
* Open accounts for individuals in the group who want to participate in IPOs.
* Distribute electronic prospectuses.
* Accept indications of interest to purchase shares in an offering.
"This proprietary system enables Wit Capital to quickly and digitally open thousands of accounts for new customers without any incremental cost to the issuer," noted Andrew Klein, the firm's founder and chief strategist.
Complementing its affinity distribution, 140,000 individual investors have navigated to Wit Capital's Internet site over the last eight months. Through co-marketing arrangements, the potential pool of investors climbs to three million, according to firm officials.
To participate in Wit Capital-sponsored IPOs, investors first need to navigate to the investment bank's web site (www.witcapital.com). New accounts must complete an investor profile. The minimum account balance is $2,000. Investors can download a preliminary prospectus from the web site and place an indication of interest.
Stock is allocated on a first-come, first-served basis, and is also based partly on a customer's investment objectives, trading experience and history, Feeley said.
Initially, the firm's capital-markets operations will be divided into five broad sectors: technology and the Internet, healthcare and life sciences, business-to-business services, information services and media and entertainment.
Wit Capital's customers will be able to access pre-IPO and post-IPO investment products, including early and middle-stage private placements; public venture capital, allowing investors the opportunity to invest in emerging companies; online brokerage services; and angel funds.
Product quality is of paramount importance for the upstart investment bank, according to Lessin. "If we put garbage through our system, the franchise is not going to last very long," he said, noting that quality distribution and maintaining syndicate relationships are important considerations.
"Obviously the screen has to be very tight. The rationale is that the Internet will become a viable means of commerce," added Lessin, who has personally invested between $100,000 and $2 million in 45 separate start-ups. "Access to capital will decide who survives, who thrives and who fails."
Online Distribution
In addition to the tracking abilities provided by electronic trading, another advantage of Internet distribution is its demographic reach, according to an official whose firm included Wit Capital in its underwriting syndicate.
Internet distribution gives underwriters access to customers likely to be familiar with a high-tech company's products and services, and are more inclined to be long-term investors. The attraction is so strong, in fact, that some IPO issuers have requested that Wit Capital be included in their underwriting syndicate.
"I used Wit Capital because I thought it would add something to a high-tech offering like ours," said Michael A. Webster, president and chief executive of Viagrafix (Nasdaq:VIAX), a Pryor, Okla.-based publisher of training courses delivered on CD-ROM, LANs, intranets and the Internet.
"We were pretty intrigued by being able to provide users access to our offering over the Internet," said Jeffrey Tauber, chief executive of CyberShop (Nasdaq:CYSP), a New York-based operator of an online mall. "As Wit develops its business model, this will be an increasingly attractive avenue of distribution for high-tech issuers."
So what's next for this avant-garde investment bank? "We have other offerings in the pipeline which are beginning to see heavier traffic," Feeley said. The latest prospective offering to emerge from that pipeline is Genesis Direct (Nasdaq:GEND), a Secaucus, N.J.-based catalog and Internet-specialty retailer.
Wit Capital also hopes to assume the lead role in upcoming offerings, Feeley noted.
To support its underwriting activities, Wit Capital is aggressively beefing up its research capabilities. The firm expects to offer proprietary analysis on its site in the next few months.
"Providing and aggregating research and facilitating a high level of communications between issuers and shareholders are important for Wit Capital's business model," Feeley said.
This year, Wit Capital will launch its Digital Stock Market, touting it as the first-ever web-based electronic trading system. The system will permit investors to buy and sell shares of select listed companies directly with other investors, supposedly without the spreads made in traditional marketplaces.
But the question remains whether Wit Capital will survive to underwrite its own IPO. If the satisfaction of its customers is any indication, don't bet against it. "I think Wit will eventually be a real player with the addition of Bob Lessin and the presence of Andrew Klein," Tauber said. "It's not going to happen overnight."
Stephen Lacey is associate editor of The IPO Reporter, a sister publication of Traders Magazine.